Operations Portal

You select Crimsonne to get into the portal and...
WHADDA YA KNOW? He turs into a music Feliz!
The next day...
You select Huggy_Bear to get into the portal and...
HE TURNS INTO A SCHOOL REESE!
The next day...
You select Crimsonne to get into the portal and...
Nothing happened.

I swear that thing has a mind of its own.
(this did not happen in order, in case certain peoples correct me...)